August: Osage County - Movie Review

Tools

By Craig Thornton

August: Osage County is the film adaption of the Pulitzer Prize and Tony winning play by Tracy Letts. I saw the Broadway production and at three hours (with two intermissions) it was riveting and immensely entertaining.  The filmmakers, including Letts who wrote the screenplay have cut the film’s length to two hours.  This truncation has many people sighing relief; as it is clear three hours of this horribly dysfunctional family yelling and degrading each other would be just too much.  However, because the story has been shortened it sometimes feels like there are transitions and moments missing between the surprises, shocks and ghastly revelations. Perhaps the problem isn’t just that the story has been shortened, but perhaps August: Osage County should have just stayed on the stage where it belonged.

Plays typically do not make good films because theater is about language and film is about images.  Plays typically have long scenes and films have short scenes.  Plot is propelled by dialogue in plays and by action in films. Plays have long speeches and films have snappy quick dialogue.  This aside, there have been some great movies made from plays in the past, and this film gets an A for effort, but it just doesn’t pack the power of the stage production.

When poet and scholar Beverly Weston (Sam Shepard) disappears form his rural Oklahoma home the family descends to wait out the crisis and verdict. The 14 cast ensemble is loaded with Hollywood thespians that have Oscars, Oscar nominations and generally stellar reputations as very good actors.  Meryl Streep received her record 18th nomination for playing the drug addicted, venomous, mother from hell Violet Weston.  I am a huge Streep fan, but this is not one of her best performances. It is not because she is afraid to make big choices, but there is something about her performance that just doesn’t feel complete, or gel.  She has brilliant moments and great moments of lucidity, but her performance teeters very close to caricature.

 

Contrarily, I am not a big Julia Roberts fan but her take on Barbara Weston- Fordham, is well controlled and she is a revelation as the embittered, cynical, resentful eldest daughter.  Cast against type, Roberts surprises with the rage that simmers just under the surface. However both of these performances are not as good as the less famous Margo Martindale’s turn as Violet’s sister Mattie Fae Aiken.  Bawdy, vicious, yet vulnerable, Martindale’s presence never feels theatrical or sketchy.  She looks like she belongs in rural Oklahoma and appears perfectly normal on the outside, even though she holds many secrets that can affect and destroy her own family’s lives.

 

Full of plot, truth telling, family fights, recriminations, deep dark secrets and the underside of human behavior, August: Osage County was a great ride on Broadway, but it is less successful on the screen. It is well acted and entertaining, but it never overcomes its talky roots and loses its emotional claustrophobic impact by expanding its canvas.  It is also littered with the most unlikeable characters I have seen in a long time, finding empathy for even the more scrupulous characters is difficult as they are the weakest characters in the film.

 

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Anonymous said on Saturday, Feb 1 at 9:08 AM

I don't agree about Meryl Streep's playing sometimes with tones of caricature. The role is very strong and sometimes touches naturally the limit of caricature by itself. I think she is perfect.As Julia Roberts, a surprise. her

170841715
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Mark said on Saturday, Feb 1 at 2:01 PM

I don't see how this is considers a comedy. There isn't anything funny about drunks, drug addicts, and families this dysfunctional. While the acting was very good, the story wasn't. I don't consider this to be entertaining at all--just very dreary and sad.

170889926
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

CeladonBlue said on Saturday, Feb 1 at 10:16 PM

Just came from the movie. Excellent review of Craig Thorton nailed it. I am a big Meryl Streep and Julia Roberts fan and since this was listed as a comedy as well as a drama I thought there would be a few moments of light. But ...two hours of watching a tale of addiction, drugs, alcohol, incest and just plain cruelty left me just...sad. This play should have stayed a play, where its power would have rung. As a movie it was constrained and just depressing.

170964231
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Germaine said on Saturday, Feb 1 at 11:37 PM

Reviewer you didn't even know that Mattie-Fae was Violet's sister - NOT sister in law as you erroneously stated. We thought the movie was wonderful, the acting amazing and the characters multi dimensional. Yes movies are different from plays and this was adapted well. We were swept up in it and didn't feel the need to compare it to the play, which we also saw. Different experience.

170976521
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Sunday, Feb 2 at 12:20 PM

This movie was no more a comedy then a man in the moon. It started dark and ended dark!! I was ready to call the suicide hotline. Good grief!!

171088745
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

2rosie said on Sunday, Feb 2 at 1:11 PM

I go to movies to be entertained. This movie was anthing but entertaining. It was degrading to women, BY women.Disgusting as far as I and my two friends were concerned. Listed as a comedy, God help us!! It started out DARK and ended even DARKER ! I want my money back!! Misrepresentation!!

171096992
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Sunday, Feb 2 at 1:28 PM

-rolls eyes- BORING. the movie, along with the review is nothing but hogwash. Do not even bother wasting your time & money, life is too short!

171099956
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

CT said on Monday, Feb 3 at 11:25 AM

Thanks for catching my mistake regarding Martindale's character-Germaine. And thanks for all the comments, it's good to know so many people are reading.

171286511
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Lee said on Tuesday, Feb 4 at 10:45 AM

I thought the only thing that could have improved this movie would have been a mass family suicide right at the start & then end the movie! It was that painful to watch! I hated every single character, and there was not even one redeeming scene in it.

171517691
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

WWNY TV 7 - News, Weather and Sports for and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

Thursday, November 27, 2014
, Watertown, NY

On Demand

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

What's On TonightFull Schedule