Movie Review - Prometheus

Tools

By Craig Thornton

Prometheus – Movie Review

Everyone obsessed with the Alien movies and everyone who loves Ridley Scott, one of our greatest cinematic stylists, has already rushed to see Prometheus. Whereas the original Alien felt like a horror film/sci-fi mash up and its sequel Aliens, directed by James Cameron, seemed like a mash up of  a horror film/sci-fi/action flick, Prometheus really just feels like a sci-fi film, well at least for most of the film.

Bombarded with symbolism and religious references and ideas about the creation of mankind, Prometheus is the intelligent person’s part of the Alien franchise.  Given this, it is no wonder, that I didn’t get much of the philosophy, theory and science behind it. I am not too intellectual, and often movies like this leave me scratching my head, and I just assume everyone else is getting the intricacies of the themes and plot that are going on.

So I called upon on all my expensive and elaborate film education from NYU film school and the American Film Institute and came up with this: WTF?

First of all, if use symbolism, please remember that not everything can be a symbol and it would help to figure out what one symbol meant before you present the next one.  There shouldn’t be the need for cliff notes every five minutes, plus they are hard to read with 3-D glasses on.

Prometheus is a masterpiece of art direction and atmosphere. It looks stunning and you feel like something bad is going to happen at any minute and for a long (a very long) time this “look and feel” keeps you interested.  There is little action, horror or death for what seems like an eternity.  Ironically though, once mayhem does descend, the film began to unravel.  I understand that typically Science Fiction films are slight on character development and big on ideas and science, but these characters are so thin you can see through them. Perhaps that is why I couldn’t care less when they start getting picked off like cat hairs on a black sweater. I can sum up my main problem with this movie in three words, “No Character Empathy.”

In both Alien and Aliens it was clear that Ripley (Sigourney Weaver) was the hero and even the people that “bought it” you felt something for.  For the longest time, I can’t figure who I am supposed to care about and why in Prometheus.  Furthermore they all seem so passive and like moronic graduates of the “don’t go in the cellar” school that I am just waiting for them to get their intergalactic, gross-out justice.  

Even though there is a prologue flashback at the beginning, involving Dr. Shaw (Noomi Rapache) as a child, that is supposed to build empathy and let us know that it is her story, the screenwriters are so busy overloading the script with other characters and storylines that we soon forget.  It isn’t until the last third or fourth of the film that Shaw emerges as a type of hero, (spoiler alert) especially after a spectacularly exciting and terrifying futuristic surgical procedure (one of the best sequences in the film).  But it all feels a little too late.  On the way to this character empathy there is great production design and interesting ideas, but also some pretty lame plotting and lack of central focus.

The writers’ smugness and cavalier attitude toward the audience’s emotional involvement is evident by the death of the most venal and evil character. Usually in horror films, “bad” characters get an astonishingly graphic death, a sort of cinematic justice.  Not so here.  Here, the death of the person you want to see get it the most is barely registered on screen and that death, like the entire film, leaves you deeply unsatisfied.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Mirko said on Saturday, Jun 23 at 2:47 AM

I didn't like this movie. I hoped for a great scifi but it wasn't. This movie is full of religious symbolism and mythological symbolysm (maybe celtic too) beginning with the name (prometheus) I grant that. But I think there is no deep developing of these symbols. I felt that half of the movie was not there. The philosophical questions asked were presented in a superficial way and the characters were not developed. This movie is also full of great idea, but agian if fell too short. I look forward for a director cut with an extra 2h....... cherio

94372045
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Jayse said on Monday, Jun 18 at 12:54 PM

This movie left me angry with it when i was done watching. There was no real "hero" the "bad guy" had a crapy death, there were all sorts of plot holes, and the whole thing made me wonder if there was a line to get my money back. that was the worst 130 M. Fox has ever spent. I was really hoping that it was going to be more like Alien, but apparently i missed me memo that they decided it wasn't a prequel and was simply in the same universe, but even there they killed their own timeline with AVP. Worst movie i've seen this year by far.

93993965
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Rowdy said on Sunday, Jun 17 at 9:24 PM

Did Ridley Scott watch the original? The eggs were in a stasis field in the original. This time they were in Roman amphorae. So how does the dead alien pilot get back to his chair with his chest blown out. Splain That?

93946136
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Sunday, Jun 17 at 4:51 PM

Movie is really bad, plot is not bright, zero action whatsoever, please save your money and rent it when it comes out if you really have to see it. Can't believe they could release a movie which is so bad.

93930785
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

MG said on Sunday, Jun 17 at 7:36 AM

In this review you mentioned that you weren't smart enough to get it, though it's obvious that you don't really think so. However, I believe you were correct. Four star film. You only have a point about the "don't go in the cellar" moments. You didn't even mention Weyland being miscast. Otherwise, a mind-bending masterpiece.

93896085
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Saturday, Jun 16 at 10:30 PM

You're an idot

93871435
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

N.L. said on Saturday, Jun 16 at 2:28 PM

AMEN! The original Alien was dark, gritty and well written. I naively was hoping for the same with Prometheus. The cliche characters were painful to watch and I wanted to leave the theater multiple times. Such amazing actors given such crappy roles. What a waste of talent and my time.

93841755
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

WWNY TV 7 - News, Weather and Sports for and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

Friday, November 28, 2014
, Watertown, NY

On Demand

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

What's On TonightFull Schedule